Christian Thought: Christian Theology & Philosophy
  • Home
  • Introduction
  • An Outline of the Bible
  • Verse Observations
  • The Ultimate Question
  • Theology
    • Cosmic Law >
      • Good & Evil/Pain & Suffering >
        • God Using Evil for Good
        • Sacrifice & Mortification
        • Judges: Irony & Meaninglessness
      • Spiritual & Physical//Natural & Supernatural >
        • Grace vs Work >
          • The Sabbath
        • Angels
      • (About) the Divine Plan/Fate & Free Will >
        • The Interwovenness of Human Lives & Their Inevitable Mutual Effects on Each Other – aka The Ripple Effect
        • Faith in God's Will >
          • Prayer
          • Tests to Determine God's Will or Approval
    • The (Actual) Divine Plan (Biblical History) >
      • Necessity of the Law & a Chosen Nation >
        • Importance of Sacrifices & the Nature of Holiness/Determination of Guilt, Under the Law
        • The Mosaic Law
      • Theological History >
        • Jewish Beliefs as Relates to Christianity
      • The Creation
      • Eschatology
    • The Attributes of God and His Character >
      • The Trinity
    • Sin & Salvation >
      • Original Sin
      • Predestination and the Elect >
        • Losing One’s Salvation/Falling from Grace/Apostasy/Perseverance >
          • Blasphemy against the Holy Spirit
      • Sin & Guilt >
        • Collective Guilt/National Sin
      • Reward & Punishment; Mercy
      • The Afterlife >
        • Heaven/the New Creation
        • Hell
        • Purgatory & the Harrowing of Hell
    • The Christian Life >
      • Receiving the Holy Spirit
      • Persecution & Hardship
      • Christian Ethics >
        • Marriage & Celibacy
      • Demon Possession & Activity
    • Determining the Truth of Christianity >
      • The Sinlessness and Perfection of God — Accusations against God >
        • Concerning Reward & Punishment >
          • Sweeping the Innocent Away with the Wicked/Many Suffer for the Sin of One >
            • The Innocent Punished for the Sins of the Wicked (to Punish the Wicked) >
              • Punishing the Children for the Father’s Sin
          • Harshness
          • Manipulation of Free Will (to the Person’s Damnation)
        • The Law of God Flawed >
          • Sins against Love (Revenge Seeking)
          • Unjust Warfare/War
          • Racism & Slavery
          • Sexism >
            • Theology of the Sexes >
              • Women’s Gender Role >
                • Submission
            • Male Chauvinism >
              • Unequal Opportunity/Deprivation of Rights
              • Polygamy
              • Women’s Chastity
            • Rape & Sex Slavery
        • Sins of People in the Bible (that Reflect Poorly on God)
      • Can We Take the Bible Seriously? >
        • The Creation of the Canon
        • False Prophecy/Broken Promises
        • Contradictions in the Bible
        • False Reasoning
    • Ambiguous/Strange/Bizarre Passages of the Bible
  • Philosophy
    • Spiritual & Physical//The Natural & Supernatural >
      • Mind & Body
      • Thinking & Doing >
        • Work
    • Metaphysics >
      • Reality
      • Generalities vs Exceptions
      • The Problem of Relativity
      • The Problem of the Distribution of Goodies (Randomness) >
        • Natural & Inevitable Inequality/The Unequal Distribution Wealth >
          • Communism
      • Cause & Effect/Human Action & Reaction
      • Beauty >
        • Art
      • Mathematics & Logic
      • Science & the Natural Laws
    • Epistemology/Faith >
      • Atheism
      • Idealism
      • Asceticism & False Religion
    • Man >
      • Created in the Image of God (Comparing Humans & Animals)
      • Sinful Nature >
        • Levels of the Will
      • Psychology >
        • The Conscious & Subconscious
        • Personality
      • Stages of Life >
        • Death
      • Society >
        • Hermitism
      • The Sexes >
        • Men
        • Women
    • History of the World >
      • How Ideas & Knowledge Spread
    • Ethics >
      • Good & Evil
      • Happiness
      • Love >
        • Romantic Love >
          • Sexuality >
            • Homosexuality

Levels of the Will

Picture
[Thanks to Gerd Altmann]
To introduce this topic, I’d like to give an illustration – I once read about a woman who was a shopping addict. Completely unable to control herself and driven to desperation, she decided to freeze her credit card in a block of ice to force herself to stop spending. I like this example because it’s so extreme and shows so nicely the division between the parts or levels of the will. On one hand, she wanted to stop. On the other, she could not. On the other, she did have enough will to do a little thing (freeze her card in ice), even though she knew this meant that she had effectively stopped her desire from running rampant, as another part of her will would like. If she wanted to control herself, why could she not control herself without resorting to some means outside herself?
    Now we do this in smaller examples too, as when we pay for gym membership or sign up for a class because we can’t compel ourselves on our own to get off our lazy asses or put our minds to work.

What if someone wants to believe, with all his heart, but can’t/doesn’t?

Rom 7:15-24 feeling guilty, even hating yourself and what you’re doing, and yet still not being able to stop. Now the reason people don’t do evil things is because it makes them feel too guilty that it’s not worth it, but we see in this that this isn’t completely true, or that we’re missing something here.

What do we say about atheists who want to believe in God and even admire people of faith, but can’t believe? What does this say about their wills, and about human will?

Wanting to sin but not being able to (split will). Pushing a button so that you never sin.

Levels of Free Will: We can rank choices by how much free will is involved. This could be a fruitful exercise.
I'd like to note that I haven't based this ranking on how much self-control the person actually has, but how little they can be blamed. So it may well be that a person who's a crack addict has extremely little control over their addiction, but I would say this person is more at fault than a bipolar person who gives into their manic rages.
level -9: being under the influence of some drug, hormone or bodily ailment, resulting in a fuzzy mind. This is the 1 level where I think the person actually has so little free will as to be exempt from blame. (EX: a drunk driver [but I'd like to note that the decision to get drunk in the first place is a level 0 {ie, neutral} decision])
level -8: being under the influence of some drug, hormone or bodily ailment, resulting in a fractured mind (that is, the person can think perfectly clearly about some things, but another part of their mind is compelled to believe whatever their brain is telling them. (EX: a schizophrenic who believes their hallucinations)
level -7: loving somebody; having certain religious, political or philosophical beliefs (This doesn't mean, however, that one cannot be open-minded and willing and eager to learn from everything and everyone. Whether you will be persuaded or not, though, is a different matter, and what I'm talking about here.)
level -6: having some natural capacity or incapacity due to temperament or brain structure/chemistry (EX: homosexuality; being perpetually depressed, being shy; being resilient)
level -5: as in level -7, being under the influence of some external brain-altering substance, but still retaining a sound mind with which to think clearly (EX: I read about a man who started looking at child porn after developing a brain tumor. The tumor was removed and his perversion went away.)
level -4: cultural influences that are difficult to debate with due to a lack of information or alternate paradigm to think about it with (performing genital mutilation on your daughter because you think it's good for her, becoming a farmer or warrior because that's what you've been taught and pretty much the only thing you know) (cf level 0)
level -3 akratic behaviors developed over time from bad habits, that is, in this case you were the external agent that changed your own brain chemistry (EX: gluttony, addictions)
level -2: akratic behavior due to bodily cravings (premarital sex, getting sloppy in your work because you're getting burned out)
level -1: personality flaws (being a pessimist, caring too much about others' opinions)
level 0: things such as deciding to brush your teeth; start a certain career; doing the right thing, even under duress (like at gunpoint); choosing sides in a debate with ir/rational thinking (EX: being brainwashed by communist propaganda or a prosperity gospel televangelist)

Being thrown into life. 

What about not being able to choose who we fall in love with? Nor do we choose our reactions. It’s only natural to have certain reactions to certain instigators. If we follow our nature, is this a violation of free will? But if we could make up our reactions, then wouldn’t everything be arbitrary? Then everything would lack meaning. Also, there would be no differentiation/variety/diversity. Now you could make it so that you have a happy reaction towards everything (but 3rd, this would also go against nature. It’s a great logical wrong for everything to warrant the same reaction), but this makes everything meaningless. Truly, this would be a form of ignorant bliss. It could even lead to disrespect (imagine, for example, appreciating being raped) and then what would be the point of having different kinds of relationships if you could have sex with everyone? (What, for example, would be the point of having parents if you could have sex with them?) Meaning comes from restriction. Meaning comes from order, and order is a type of restriction. Also, fun comes from restriction (rules). Games are played by rules. But restriction means particulars. It means going from the unified abstract to the divided concrete.

​Why is it that people can't act unless their emotions are engaged? Why can't reason act on its own? Then when we are reasonable and control our emotions, what's going on there?

​Wanting to forgive yourself but being unable to do so. This is a more interesting question than wanting to forgive someone else but being unable to do so. In the latter, it's arguable whether you really want to forgive or not. In the former, it's taken for granted that you really do, since we all love ourselves above others.
Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.