Christian Thought: Christian Theology & Philosophy
  • Home
  • Introduction
  • An Outline of the Bible
  • Verse Observations
  • The Ultimate Question
  • Theology
    • Cosmic Law >
      • Good & Evil/Pain & Suffering >
        • God Using Evil for Good
        • Sacrifice & Mortification
        • Judges: Irony & Meaninglessness
      • Spiritual & Physical//Natural & Supernatural >
        • Grace vs Work >
          • The Sabbath
        • Angels
      • (About) the Divine Plan/Fate & Free Will >
        • The Interwovenness of Human Lives & Their Inevitable Mutual Effects on Each Other – aka The Ripple Effect
        • Faith in God's Will >
          • Prayer
          • Tests to Determine God's Will or Approval
    • The (Actual) Divine Plan (Biblical History) >
      • Necessity of the Law & a Chosen Nation >
        • Importance of Sacrifices & the Nature of Holiness/Determination of Guilt, Under the Law
        • The Mosaic Law
      • Theological History >
        • Jewish Beliefs as Relates to Christianity
      • The Creation
      • Eschatology
    • The Attributes of God and His Character >
      • The Trinity
    • Sin & Salvation >
      • Original Sin
      • Predestination and the Elect >
        • Losing One’s Salvation/Falling from Grace/Apostasy/Perseverance >
          • Blasphemy against the Holy Spirit
      • Sin & Guilt >
        • Collective Guilt/National Sin
      • Reward & Punishment; Mercy
      • The Afterlife >
        • Heaven/the New Creation
        • Hell
        • Purgatory & the Harrowing of Hell
    • The Christian Life >
      • Receiving the Holy Spirit
      • Persecution & Hardship
      • Christian Ethics >
        • Marriage & Celibacy
      • Demon Possession & Activity
    • Determining the Truth of Christianity >
      • The Sinlessness and Perfection of God — Accusations against God >
        • Concerning Reward & Punishment >
          • Sweeping the Innocent Away with the Wicked/Many Suffer for the Sin of One >
            • The Innocent Punished for the Sins of the Wicked (to Punish the Wicked) >
              • Punishing the Children for the Father’s Sin
          • Harshness
          • Manipulation of Free Will (to the Person’s Damnation)
        • The Law of God Flawed >
          • Sins against Love (Revenge Seeking)
          • Unjust Warfare/War
          • Racism & Slavery
          • Sexism >
            • Theology of the Sexes >
              • Women’s Gender Role >
                • Submission
            • Male Chauvinism >
              • Unequal Opportunity/Deprivation of Rights
              • Polygamy
              • Women’s Chastity
            • Rape & Sex Slavery
        • Sins of People in the Bible (that Reflect Poorly on God)
      • Can We Take the Bible Seriously? >
        • The Creation of the Canon
        • False Prophecy/Broken Promises
        • Contradictions in the Bible
        • False Reasoning
    • Ambiguous/Strange/Bizarre Passages of the Bible
  • Philosophy
    • Spiritual & Physical//The Natural & Supernatural >
      • Mind & Body
      • Thinking & Doing >
        • Work
    • Metaphysics >
      • Reality
      • Generalities vs Exceptions
      • The Problem of Relativity
      • The Problem of the Distribution of Goodies (Randomness) >
        • Natural & Inevitable Inequality/The Unequal Distribution Wealth >
          • Communism
      • Cause & Effect/Human Action & Reaction
      • Beauty >
        • Art
      • Mathematics & Logic
      • Science & the Natural Laws
    • Epistemology/Faith >
      • Atheism
      • Idealism
      • Asceticism & False Religion
    • Man >
      • Created in the Image of God (Comparing Humans & Animals)
      • Sinful Nature >
        • Levels of the Will
      • Psychology >
        • The Conscious & Subconscious
        • Personality
      • Stages of Life >
        • Death
      • Society >
        • Hermitism
      • The Sexes >
        • Men
        • Women
    • History of the World >
      • How Ideas & Knowledge Spread
    • Ethics >
      • Good & Evil
      • Happiness
      • Love >
        • Romantic Love >
          • Sexuality >
            • Homosexuality

Reward & Punishment; Mercy

Picture
Picture
Verse Observations: Ezr 9:13, II Cor 7:11, Jb 42:8, Ps 25:7, chps 38 & 39, 103:10, Jer 7:20, 46:28, Ezk 8:18
*When does God extend mercy? - Ps 32:6

Is this not contradictory? (Dt 7:9, Ex 34:7)

In the time of the judges, why did God save the Israelites when he knew they wouldn’t repent? In fact the bible even says that they would just get worse and worse. (Jdgs 2:11-19) Even Gideon in his own lifetime turned away from God. (Jdgs 8:27)

​I Chr 21:12 Are these 3 choices really equal?


Lam 3:65 How can God ever give this as punishment, and/or how can this ever be prayed for, since it turns sins into a disposition, one that could even be eternal?

Jdgs 2:2-3, 20-22 Why would God punish them by allowing them to become idolators? Isn’t that the opposite of what he wanted? (Dt 4:28)

Zec 11:4-17 (see also Is 3:1-15) This is quite ironic, and yet also a paradox. On one hand, if the people are evil, what the people need, now more than ever, is good leaders. If God wants to solve the problem, this is what he should do to see change, so his decision makes no sense. On the other hand, it also makes sense to punish the people by making their lives worse, in which case, God's decision would be effective, and yet, this will only make the people more evil. Of course, eventually, something's gotta give and we know God is merciful and can be expected to be gracious. The question is -- after how long; at what point, and why at that point? When and for how long does God choose to punish or be gracious and save?

How could this punishment have been effective if Hezekiah didn't care that all these things would happen, so long as they didn't happen in his own time? (II Kgs 20:13-19)


Ps 83: 16 & 17 are contradictory, and one follows right after the other, so this needs an explanation.
Fill their faces with shame, that they may seek your name, O LORD. Let them be put to shame and dismayed forever; let them perish in disgrace


When God extends mercy, does he then not fully punish? Amos prayed to God to relent of the disaster that he was going to send, but whatever would be the point of this if they had to be fully punished anyway? Now or later, right. Sooner or later. The point is, it has to come. And it would be the same amount/degree of punishment no matter its timing. But if Amos’ prayer worked, because it was a true and righteous prayer, then this would imply that God does not fully punish, that you can be saved from this. (Am 7:1-9)
Should a person still be punished even though they've repented?

If God is kind to the ungrateful and evil, what makes him decide to finally punish? (Lk 6:35)

Jer 15:4 Manasseh repented, so why didn't God relent? Why is God sometimes merciful and sometimes not, even when a person repents?

Ezk 6:9-10 vs Rv 9:20-21 Why is it that sometimes people repent and sometimes they don’t? 

Why should anybody be punished double for their sins?
punished doubly – Rv 18:6, Jer 16:18

If teachers are punished more harshly because a higher standard is applied to them, what’s the good of being better? You’ll be punished more harshly! (Jas 3:1) Look at what happened to Moses! (Nm 20:12)


Ps 102 If the psalmist is being punished for his sins, why bother to pray to God to alleviate his punishment? Would this even work? Will God shorten one's punishment?

Jer 9:17-21 Why here does God tell Jeremiah to mourn, but in 16:5 he says not to?

Can these punishments really be said to be equal? Famine is a slow death that worries the heart, death by the sword strikes terror, but pestilence is quick (and therefore it makes sense that this is the one that David picked). (II Sm 24:13)

Ezk 29:19-20 How could God pay them for evil, especially when he planned to punish them for it? (see, for example, Jer 50:17-18, 51:20-25 & chps 50-51 generally)

Why would God punish the one who killed Cain seven times instead of say, ½? The point is, why would the one who wanted mere vengeance be punished more than for what Cain did - murdering out of jealousy? In fact, why did God let Cain get away with murder? (Gn 4:15)

Not everybody has been cursed completely for their sins. Some people like their jobs. And then some people are hunter-gatherers who spend only about 3 hours a day on surviving. The rest of the time they can do whatever they want and they have tons of leisure time. Then how is God’s curse of work effective for these groups of people? And some women never experience childbirth, so how do they experience Eve’s part of the curse? (Gn 5:28-29, 3:16-19)


How is it possible that a good man could be cursed with evil sons? (Samuel) (I Sm 8:1-3)

Why would God want his own temple to be profaned? (Ezk 7:22)

How are the wicked a ransom for the righteous? (Prv 21:18)

Why would God make it so that people can only appreciate a certain aspect of his creation? Couldn't we consider this a form of punishment, a smaller radius of happiness, some having smaller radii than others?
Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.